Best Cookie Shop Fayetteville Near Me

Deanna Harmon: Went one night and honestly, Walmart cupcakes taste better 🙃. It was so overpriced for the quality.Customer service was not good at all either..They tasted dry and stale, no moisture at all. I'm so sad cause I was hoping they were worth the hype they get. 😭

Monica Clayton: Pleasant shop and the young lady that helped me was friendly and patient. Unfortunately, a couple of the cupcakes didn’t seem fresh, specifically the butter beer cupcake which was very hard and honestly just inedible. Maybe I caught them on an off day.

Sarah Rogers: Got my daughters 13th birthday cake custom made. They did a fabulous job and got the design right, and the cake was moist and everyone loved it.

Todd W.: I decided to try the brownie that has cheesecake in the middle. The brownie was no better quality than the brownies served at Roy Rogers fast food, meaning the taste was not great. Plus the brownies are small. I was not impressed.

Jobe Morrisey: Great customer service, we went on a Sunday afternoon, I got the key lime cheesecake, it was refreshing and delicious, I tore it up before taking a photo, 😩sorry but my son got the cupcakes, and vanilla pudding and I got the photo of those🤗

Megan Green: i’ve ordered off of uber eats so I know the treats are good! but my first time coming in the girl in the front seemed a little rushed or on edge despite there not really being a crowd. I asked for a vanilla cone with sprinkles and got a bowl with barely any sprinkles. my cone fell off because it wasn’t ice cream in it to begin with :/

cindy okeefe: I’ve been to Sweet Tooth many times. Everything I’ve tried has been delicious!! The cheesecake slices, pecan pie squares, cookies and cupcakes were all great. My dogs love the doggie treat bars! Very nice, helpful staff.

Jan Beiswanger: We ordered a Birthday Cake for our Mother’s 95th birthday from Sweet Tooth Bakery. The Sweet Tooth staff were very nice and made suggestions to help us with our order. The cake turned out so beautiful and it was absolutely delicious. I can’t tell you how excited my Mother was when she saw her birthday cake. She loved it! Thank you Sweet Tooth Bakery for making her 95th birthday so special.

Kim Washabaugh: This bakery is phenomenal. When we moved to the area, my daughter’s birthday was coming up, and with an allergy, I needed a Vegan shop for a cake. We ordered a jumbo cupcake, and not only was it incredibly affordable, but it was also possibly the best cupcake I’ve had ever. Since then we’ve stopped in for small treats an I’ve never had anything that was not amazing. Absolutely recommend!

Christopher Barnes: Everything bet is DELICIOUS! The customer service is excellent, as well. The gluten free cupcakes are the best I’ve ever tasted!!!!

laura powers: I have had many items from The Sweet Tooth. The macaroons are yummy. I love the cupcakes always spot on. My granddaughter loves the keto cheesecake. I have ordered 3 specialty cakes made for my grands birthdays always what I asked for. I also love to have a cup of the ice cream. The customer service has always been amazing. They go above and beyond in my book.

Subrena Guy: They have the best cupcakes flavors!!

Makiba Ahearn: Cupcakes were ok. More like muffins with frosting.

Josias Charles: Thank you sweet tooth shop for making an exceptionally delicious cake and cup cakes for my wedding reception.

Levi: Hershey ice cream friendly services. I'm coming back to try the coffee and other goodies. Cheese cake, cup cakes, cookies, regular cakes, and vegan options it all looked great.

Kate Murdoe: Huge variety of different kinds of sweets and flavors. Very clean and relaxed atmosphere. The cupcakes and coffee were delicious!!

M Harris: Only two flavors for gluten free, but they taste incredible. Very moist, rich flavor, and the icing compliments it perfectly.

Brett W: I’ve visited this shop multiple times. Every time I get the best costumer service. Every item in there is amazing. The cheesecake and cupcakes are my absolute favorite. Also, I love that they have something for everyone.

Es Niicole: I’m sorry … this my first time trying this spot today and everyone taste buds are different but my cupcakes were so dry , I thought I was in the Sahara desert . The icing was okay though .Edit : I got a Oreo cheesecake as well &’ it was deliciousssssssssss . I would definitely purchase that again . Lol

Porshe Lowery: Okay so.... I purchased two cupcakes, a piece of cheesecake, and two macarons. Macaroons had that perfect crunchy/chewiness that not everybody can capture. Delicious! The cheesecake was really good. I like a little bit more tart but still VERY creamy and delicious. The cupcakes is where it gets dicey. The cake was moist and had a great taste. Great bite. Not too crumbly but still soft and fluffy. The icing however was a let down. I got a strawberry and a birthday cake. The birthday cake wasn't too bad but the icing on the strawberry cupcake tasted like straight oil. I felt like I was eating a strawberry flavored whipped olive oil. It was gross. I was confused bc the strawberry flavored came through but the oil was just too overpowering. Maybe just a fluke. But not a fan.

Brenda Tucker: Delicious!!!

Kimberly Lucas: Burneys is the best. The service and the goodies are always good. Love Burney's!!

Monica L Morgan: Tried Burney's last month when I was in town, it was good. Made the mistake of going back and it was not good at all. The apple fritter was thick and doughy and lacked apples. Honey or something was missing with the honeybun. Very disappointed.

Johnnie Bryant: Went in last week and they had nothing that we asked for. (Fritter, Bearclaw). Don’t advertise what you don’t have. Not only didn’t they have what we asked for, she didn’t even make an attempt to see if we wanted anything else or when it would be available. Terrible service. Waste of drive.

Jeff Vaughan: Awesome

Tina Louise: Stopped in because the pictures looked so good...they do not do the goodies justice! And the staff is super welcoming!

Eve Lynch: Friendly staff and great dessert 🍰

Whitney A: I needed a simple red velvet cake for a family members birthday celebrations and found Burney’s online. I went in person on a early Friday afternoon to place the order, the girl taking my order seem new because she didn’t seem to know what was going on when writing my order down. I was told to email my inspiration picture because the lady taking my order didn’t know how to describe it and I would say the decorations idea was simple. I emailed the picture, set pick up for Monday at noon, paid for the cake in advance, and left out. An hour goes by and I notice the email didn’t go through, so I called the store back and asked if they could verify they received my email but the lady that answered the phone said she didn’t have access to the email and the person would call me back. Well I never received a call back, until I gave them at 8am Monday morning to make sure they got the picture. On the phone call Monday morning a young lady informed me the person who controlled the email was still not in work but assured me my cake would be ready by noon. I go in at noon to pick up the cake and I was just baffled by the presentation. It was so sloppy and had icing missing from the bottom at the cake board but I had to accept the cake because I had to have it to the celebration 30 minutes later. Once I took it out the cake box you can see places were the icing was put on thick enough and could see the red velvet underneath and it was sliding off the cake board. We cut into the cake and taste like it had been frozen and smelled like cardboard. I feel like my cake was rushed and just slapped together.

Amber Kim: Artificial, boxed, and frozen. I don’t know how this place has 4.5 stars. The staff was helpful but those sweets were horrid.

Han Jang: I've tried a wide assortment of desserts here. Some of them are a little too sweet, but in general I enjoy stopping here!

Juan Ramos: I arrived at 1:00 and they stopped serving coffee so I can't rate their drinks. The line wasn't long and I decided to order some muffins, an eclair, and a Raspberry lemon drop.Everything tasted alright.I might have arrived too late on a Saturday to see their full assortment of treats.

T. Council- Orellana: Great service and desserts

Rosezatte McGee: I like this place somewhat, but the best bakery is none other than SUPERIOR BAKERY IN HOPEMILLS. They have the best iced and filled crossiants and doughnuts and pastries cookies. Heck everything they have there is No. 1#. Love Superior Bakery.

Chasity Sullivan: Burney's delivered a million croissants for our wedding - way better than a wedding cake! Love them

Dan LaVorgna: Fantastic pastries.

Burning Neutron: Friendly staff. Donuts and glazed croissant, donuts and good cheese cake. They have other things too. Staff is very helpful.

Matt M.: I love going to Superior but now that I have been introduced to Burney’s, this will be our new spot (it’s closer and hits the same way). I literally had to stop myself from consuming the dozen assorted glazed and filled croissants we bought. So freaking good!!

Tina Davis: This week was the first time I learned of this establishment. We are celebrating National Laboratory Week at the hospital and I found an eight foot table covered in boxes of pastries from Burney's. I took a few and was amazed at how fresh and delicious they were. I am not sure if they come with a next day, freshness guarantee but I took a few again this morning and it felt as if it was fresh from the bakery. Great job! I hope to visit in person soon to see the entire selection.

Sal DeGrazio: Best. Bakery. Ever.

Julie Rice: I got their pumpkin spice croissants today and O M G! It tastes just like a pumpkin pie. So so good. Lots of creamy filling in them.

Robert Stoltz (Stoltzbro): Best cookie (snickerdoodle) I've ever had in my life. No joke.

Metal Detecting and Coin Collecting Arrowhead Hunt: The kids loved the ice cream, and the cookies were great

Grant Barker: Just tried a cookies n cream cheesecake bite and now I want to eat like 15 more.

THERESSA THERESSA: My daughter's favorite place when we come to Fayetteville NC. She loves the variety of macaroons. We come every time we are in town and she has never been disappointed and they taste great. I have also tried the cup cakes and they're so good not too sweet but just right and very moist. They have inside and outside seating.

N White: Artsy little place to grab some sweets while checking out downtown Fayetteville. We enjoy the cupcakes and the atmosphere. They also do orders so it is nice to be able grab some goodies for a special occasion. Indoor and outdoor seating with a friendly, helpful staff.

Anissa: Nice atmosphere and good treats

Sebastian Lum: Told me they do not do birthday cakes

Julia Martinez: You see these empty plates? Enough said.

Amber Arteaga: I ordered 3 dozen macarons for my daughters sweet 16 and she was honest and flexible with the colors and flavors since she did have a theme. The flavor was great and everyone loved them!

Masha Kozhanova: Very nice atmosphere, good desserts!

Carla Wint: My new go-to place for macaroons!!! So good! So good!

Maggie Lowry: All the macarons are delicious, vibe is so cozy with lots of board games to play, great staff.

Robin Laulani Patrick Owens: Love going there. The owner is great. They are supporting the Fayetteville Ukulele Club.

Mark Conneway: Such a fun little place downtown! Really they have a huge space including the back room. Next time I go I'll update with back room pics. Ice cream, cupcakes, macaroons, all delicious!

Maggie Cannon: I went today and had a great experience! The two workers were SO kind and helpful. They even grabbed something from the back that they didn’t have out front so I could take it to go. The desserts were all delicious and I will definitely be back!

Marguerite Elsenbroek: Cupcakes were good, but really didn't see or taste the fillings.

KC Brown: Ice cream was good and staff was nice

Stephanie Bracey: I placed an order of custom cookies for my mother’s 60th birthday and they were perfect! They were exactly what I described and the service when placing the order and pick up were amazing!

Brandon Wilder: Amazingly awesome hidden treasure of Fayetteville, absolute must if your visiting. The baked goods are awesome & the Art work is a great visual experience to enjoy with tasty treats!!

Kenda Snyder: I am super picky about desserts but let me tell you I definitely plan on coming back ..We stopped in here during the Zombie walk and tried several of their desserts ..The Red Velvet cupcake was amazing .My son got the Oreo cheesecake bite and I took a bite let’s just say you will not regret trying it ..I hope this honest review helps others decide to give this place a chance it will not disappoint

Katrina Jackson: It was my intention to only eat half of a cupcake…. Two minutes later, I consumed it all!! Moist, delicious and the customer service is great as well! Will be a continued customer.

Stephanie Sanfeliz: OMG... Their banana pudding!!! My husband has a super sweet tooth and came back from them with cupcakes, red velvet cake slices and some banana pudding. It is all deliccccccccious!!!! I do NOT like slices of banana in my pudding, but the very little slices I had in this were perfect! They were thick slices so they didn't turn mushy and complimented everything perfectly!! My new addiction

Harley Smith: Absolutely love Kiss Me Cakes! Staff is super sweet and helpful, they're quick with answering any questions you might have and their cakes are delicious!! They made us a banana pudding cake for our baby shower and everyone loved it! We will definitely be ordering from them again!

James cope: They made a coconut cake for my mom's 80th birthday and she said it was the best coconut cake she has ever eaten. Her guest thought the same thing. We love their food.!!!!

Kelsey: Amazing chocolate chip cookies. Ordered ahead for 24 chocolate chip cookies for a birthday gift. Fiance loved them! Very delicious and unique choc chip cookies, packed with care. I will definitely buy more in the future. Thanks a bunch!Edit: Ordered 2 dozen more chocolate chip cookies to be shipped via mail. Angie is so nice. Awesome quick reply and follow up communication. My fiance and I love the cookies here! I'll continue to be a repeat customer.

Cassie Bejma: Probably the softest cake I've ever had!I went in last minute for a cake my daughter's birthday and they fortunately had one full cake left (it was near closing time) and offered to customize it as well. It was the "vanilla crush" flavor and it was amazing! For me, the almond flavor was a little strong so I might get the plain vanilla next time but my husband loved it so that may just be personal taste. The cake was so light and soft and moist, it was perfect!(The sprinkles and toppers were added by me. I'm sure their decorations are much fancier lol)

Alexi Downey: We got my daughter's birthday cookies from here last year and they were phenomenal. We decided to get cookies and add a smash cake to our order this year. We were sadly disappointed by the quality of the decorations this year. Everything tastes great, it was just the decorations that was very lack luster and the wrong color. The cake was very uneven, just seemed like it was someone's first time decorating.

brittany johnson: Angie did my wedding cake October 16th & it was absolutely delightful! I had guests texting me the next day asking where it was from. I had gotten a 2 tier caramel cake with buttercream frosting for 60 people; the cake was very flavorful, moist, and looked exactly like my reference picture. The cake was delivered to the venue & set up by the bakery well before the ceremony. The customer service is always excellent & she responds quickly to emails. Even if you don’t need a wedding cake, go check out her bakery for her cupcakes or brownies; the brownies are the best I’ve ever had! I’d give more than 5 stars if I could

Lynn Thornton: Absolutely wonderful cakes and cupcakes . I’ve tried many of them and was never disappointed!

Mary Morrison: Ordered for a company birthday party, added 6 cupcakes while picking up our order. The cake was beautiful, moist, and delicious. The cupcakes were full of flavor and beautifully decorated. This is the first cake I have ordered, however I regularly pick up a dozen cupcakes when I'm close by. Thank you for you consistent quality and service.

yuelonda outlaw: A friend received a beautiful birthday cake from Kiss Me Cakes. It was chocolate iced an rich moist chocolate cake. Best cake I've had in years!!! I'm hoping they ship would love to send my grandson one in Philadelphia.

Monica Lee-Jones: My family loves this place!!!! Vanilla Crush if you know, you know.

Christina Lafield: If I could give this bakery 0 stars I would! We used to come in all the time for the cupcakes which taste good but aren’t AMAZING like you can easily find at more upscale successful local bakeries and not this joke of an establishment. I went in last night to see if they would allow me to purchase two small cardboard cake rounds, as we are unable to afford an expensive cake for my toddlers birthday, we opted to make it at home this year. Without knowing that we frequent this bakery and usually buy a dozen cupcakes at a time, the young girl behind the counter gave me attitude and replied sarcastically that she couldn’t sell me two small pieces of cardboard for whatever reason. Upon leaving the store she chuckled to herself and made the whole situation very uncomfortable. Not to mention I wasn’t greeted to begin with and she had me stand and wait while she finished up her conversation with her friend that was visiting. 🤦🏻‍♀️ To be frank, you lost my business as well as every recommendation I’ve been asked for in regards to a bakery. Your bakery was the reason I began making my children’s cakes at home. I had messaged you 2 years ago for a custom birthday cake and after minimal communication, the owner just decided to not make the cake I guess and ceased communication with me. One, if you’re going to charge an arm and a leg for your cakes, maybe add a bit more creativity to them or skill? Two, if you’re going to continue making boring, expensive and homemade looking plain cakes… you should really work on your customer service and business keeping skills. From reading these reviews, I am not the only lost customer of yours to have an issue with all of the above. Below I’ve attached what a cake worth half the price you charge looks like and the creativity you may want to start adding to yours. I feel bad for the people who think y’all are the bees knees, because they’ve clearly never seen a baking show. Oh an these are also cakes I made since y’all couldn’t get back to me about making a sugar skull cake 2 years ago. Thank you for the inspiration!

David: Absolutely disappointed with the lack of understanding and customer service from THE OWNER. Placed an order and paid in full. The owner took my order and payment but failed to inform me that there was a 50% non-refundable fee. I had called back to cancel the order the same day a few hours later and at that point informed me of the non-refundable fee. The owner stated the policy was at the bottom of the receipt after I already paid. I asked for a full refund since I was not made aware of the policy and would have been positively certain of arrangements with my step daughters graduation dessert. I informed her of the full situation and asked for compassion. The owner then compared reciting business policy to that of Wal-Mart “you don’t expect Wal-Mart to recite their policy every time you make a purchase I don’t do that every time an order is placed either.” She stated my order being in the book cost her potential business. I told her I understand as a business owner you get last minute cancellations and that costs you money which was why I was extending the courtesy of canceling as soon as I knew I did not need the order. She then Went on to say in other words the the time she had to spend on the phone with me was a cost to her. She said she would go as high as refunding 75%. I told her I thought it would be fair to be refunded the amount paid less the credit card processing fee for the inconvenience. I asked her how much the fee was and She went to go check numbers and came back saying the most she could do is 75% and that she did not have to disclose the account fee to me which is the owners right. The order had not been worked on and no special items had to be ordered to complete my purchase. I had simply just booked an order for May 28th. I paid roughly $116 and was refunded $87. I had to plead with the owner and make a federal case out of the issue for several minutes in order to be shown some compassion. I don’t expect special treatment but this was not the typical last minute cancellation and I was NOT made aware of a 50% non-refundable fee. With major corporations it’s common knowledge you have a Grace period for full refunds with restrictions. This is a small business and I was treated like major corporations treat their consumers!Update: Filed a disputed transaction claim with my credit card company and was fully reimbursed. Still very disappointed the owner wasn’t able to resolve it at her level. Recommend staying away.

Jeff Horne: Love this place, recommendation five stars.

SR T.: Trash!!! Don’t waste your time or money!

Jackie Roberson: Went by to get cookies to gift to staff for a treat and a couple pieces of cake. The cookies were awesome, I got the butter pecan/ sugar/ chocolate chip and by far the butter pecan was the biggest hit. I also got the sweet potato and red velvet cake, both were moist and delicious. I will be returning!

Lauren Quinones: The icing was too sweet, the cupcakes were small

Ladavia53 Roberson: I love this bakery and you can taste the love in their cakes.

Glory Frederickson: I bought a really adorable cake from them super cute and delicious, I love the almond flavor cake! They also have super delicious cupcake flavors and I love that they have military discount!