Best Cookie Shop Cary Near Me

The Cookie Craving Crumbl Cookies - Morrisville Once In A Blue Moon Bakery & Cafe Sugar Buzz Bakery & Cafe Custom Confections, LLC Smallcakes La Farm Bakery Cinnaholic Great Harvest Bread Co - Cary Annelore's German Bakery La Michoacana Bakery Insomnia Cookies

1. Baked Cookies & Dough - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 93 reviews

107 Edinburgh S Dr Ste 115, Cary, NC 27511

Address Website WhatsApp
Baked Cookies & Dough: what do users think?
ronshawn lambert: It was pretty great I enjoyed the cookie Sunday, the chocolate chip cookie was to die for and if you enjoy a good peanut butter cookie, this is a must try.
Bill O'Neill: My wife is very picky about her choice of soft serve ice cream, and this place hits the spot! Great to support a small independent business as well!!
Adriel Gregory: Tried for the first time. I grew up on soft serve ice. This place is great. The service was great. The portions were very good. I tried the soft serve twist. Also tried chocolate chip cookie very good. We will be back. This is must try for dessert.
Lyn H: Super friendly staff, amazing variety of cookie & edible dough flavors! Soft serve ice cream was fantastic along with the cookie dough & huge cookies! Loved the cookies the most 💖, soft & chewy perfection 😍!
Galatic Cat: Absolutely amazing desert shop and owner! Remembers us every time we come back, always get rewards, and always the best milkshakes! Love this place. I hope it never leaves!
Lizzy Wilson: So many flavors and the cookies are huge!
The Telfairs: This place is very pretty on the inside.They have a lot to choose from for everyone’s sweet taste desires lol. They give a LOT of ice cream, too much if you ask me. And you get to choose a lot of toppings.I brought my mom and daughter along and everyone was happy!
Linda Queen: Workers are so nice and the desserts are so amazing. Very recommended!
Sarah Smith: If you are looking for a great environment, amazing treats and a wide variety then go to Mixed! I absolutely love this establishment. The owner and staff are always kind and the space is clean. This is great to go by yourself or with a group! Very family friendly and the selection is great!
Sydney Halsey: The absolute best and most delicious treat! I love this place and keep going back. They have great prices and the staff is always so nice! I love the selection! Definitely check them out!
Jason Ortega: I got the ice cream sandwich and my wife tried the ice cream, cookie batter, and chocolate chip cookie. This was seriously the best dessert place I’ve been to in a long time. 10/10!!
Kavya Sriram: Tasty dough and friendly staff.
Shemia Thomas: friendly staff, nice portions
Mark Conneway: Stopped in about 2mins until closing and got four amazing cookies. We'll be back! They were absolutely delicious! Be prepared to run a few miles after that carb/calorie load! 😂😂
Bizzie Hall: Great desserts, reasonable prices, and a friendly staff. Very much enjoyed our experience. We got the milkshake with salted caramel cookie dough and the fudge brownie frozen blend.
Gray C: Fantastic deserts and the girl at the front, Meg, was incredibly sweet and helpful.
Isaiah Owen: Big Dawg like!!!!!
Takecia Denning: Tried this place for the first time last week & don't understand the hype. It's a cute clean place but the sugar cookie I tried was so dry. I'll stick to Mrs. Field's cookies at the mall which are moist & has a much better flavor.
Lisa McCorkle: This is a cute colorful shop conveniently located in McGregor Village in Cary. The service is very helpful and friendly. We ordered milk shakes. They were tasty, but they tasted more like vanilla soft serve than the flavor indicated.
Let Love Brew: Came on a whim after another plan fell through, and so glad we did! The cookie dough was so good it was hard to pick just one!

2. The Cookie Craving - Raleigh

Verified

Verified

· 6 reviews

3. Crumbl Cookies - Morrisville - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 1887 reviews

1105 Market Center Drive, Morrisville, NC 27560

Address Website WhatsApp

4. Once In A Blue Moon Bakery & Cafe - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 437 reviews

115 W Chatham St Suite G, Cary, NC 27511

Address Website WhatsApp
Once In A Blue Moon Bakery & Cafe: what do users think?
Jose Iduate: Wow. This was an amazing wedding cake made to perfection. Thanks to Fred for making this such an unforgettable event.
zozo H: Cute, clean store with friendly staff and a variety of desserts to choose from. We settled on a carrot cake and variety cupcakes. The carrot cake was one of the best I’ve tried in North Carolina so far. It had a cream cheese frosting, but wasn’t overpowering. The cake was perfectly spiced and had carrot shavings in it. The cupcakes were delicious as well. I would highly recommend this bakery.
Mara Price: Our experience with this bakery was wonderful! I wanted a heart-shaped cake with a simple, custom design for my wedding shower. It was less than a month away, and I was worried I wouldn't be able to get a cake in time. But this bakery really came through. We got chocolate cake with strawberry mousse and it was DELICIOUS. And the design, pastel orange with darker orange piping and hearts and our names in a beautiful script, was perfect. It was my dream cake, and everyone loved it! The customer service was also top notch. I will definitely be ordering from Blue Moon again.
CM WH: This is my go-to bakery! Every cake I’ve ordered from this bakery turns out beautiful and delicious! The staff is friendly and efficient and the prices for specialty cakes are reasonable! I’ve appreciated how I can call and order a cake just a few days before an event without a problem. I no longer live in Cary, but farther away and still will drive to OIABM for a celebration cake because I trust the quality of their products.
Sharita Lamb: Cake really dry and lacked flavor
David Pynaker: Great cupcake and excellent service.
Jacob McAlpine: They baked my groom’s cake and wedding cake. They were helpful and accommodating throughout the process. The cake tasted as wonderful as it looked. I would recommend them if you are considering.
cindy f: Awesome cakes!
Lynn Canada: Still in business after 20 years. Obvious why.Very nice staff.Excellent cakes, cookies, cupcakes to choose from, even later in day.Took out of town company there and they were impressed, and enjoyed their purchases! Me, too!!
Maite Molina: I used Once in a Blue Moon for my husband and I's wedding cake, and the team there knocked it out of the park! They were so easy to work with and created a beautiful, tasty cake that everyone loved.
Tracy Dingeman: I ordered a cake for a graduation party and it was decorated so beautifully. The cake was moist and delicious! I wasn’t surprised because prior cakes i’ve ordered have been wonderful. When you need a cake for an event, it’s nice to have a place that’s always consistent with quality and service.
Ashley Danforth: WOW!!! I am so impressed by this bakery. I ordered a custom cake for the grand opening of my local business and they did an absolutely AMAZING job. Not only was the cake beautiful (exactly what I envisioned), but it tastes as great as it looks! 10/10!
Ashley Bunce: Amazing food, service, and employees. Will definitely be back again! The gluten free options are delicious 😋
Linda Endow Hall: My daughter-in-law purchased a chocolate birthday cake for her son, and it was not only delicious but also so beautiful!
Megurine Mayhem: Cake was absolutely beautiful (a relative added the dogwood flowers, which aren't included with the cake. Lime is included) and guests loved it. Just the right amount of sweetness and margarita lime tang. They serve great coffee, cakes, and other baked goods as well!
Payton Emerick: Once in a Blue Moon Bakery went above and beyond! I ordered a cake for my sons first birthday, and I got the dates mixed up for pickup. Completely my fault. The staff got back to me after hours and made it possible for me to get my sons birthday cake. The cake was also beautifully decorated and absolutely delicious! Highly recommend this bakery! Thank you again for saving the day! This mom really appreciates you!!
Shannon Whitehead: Once In A Blue Moon did an excellent job with our wedding cake! They were so nice and accommodating throughout the entire process, from vision to execution to delivery at our wedding venue. We showed them photos of what we were thinking and they pulled it off wonderfully. I wish I still had the original inspiration photo we showed. You can't see it in the photos but there's a lovely gold stripe on the side of our cake, too. We would definitely recommend their wedding cake services and truly can't thank them enough!
Kusham Rani: We got the best cake ever!
n K: I have been getting our birthday cakes for my entire family from here for the past 4 years. They always look and taste so great!
Randy Reed: Been going there for over 20 years. Been to many bakeries since living in Cary. They made my daughter's wedding cake and it was fabulous.
Shao: I got different flavors cupcakes for my friend’s birthday, but I didn’t care for it at all😫. Bakery is cute and friendly staff.

5. Sugar Buzz Bakery & Cafe - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 146 reviews

1231 Kildaire Farm Rd, Cary, NC 27511

Address Website WhatsApp
Sugar Buzz Bakery & Cafe: what do users think?
Amanda Lindsey-Law: Consistently the best gluten free treats and friendly service. Jonathon and Dory are always great and make the visit extra special.
Jennifer Bubel: Friggin’ Heaven!! Holy wow… I tried a red velvet cupcake with cream cheese frosting and on a whim, I grabbed a raspberry bar even though I’m usually more a straight-chocolate fan… these are some of the *genuinely* best pastries I’ve had in a while. Most places are pretty tasty and even more visually appealing… but this place is DELICIOUS. Straight. Up. Uniquely. Divine. I’m from out of town, but I *will* be bookmarking these guys for future orders… you will not regret stopping here.
Tristan Hendricks: Five stars because there isn't an option for six. Best brownie and red velvet cupcake we've ever had and the service was wonderful.
Guitar Hero: By all means avoid this place so I can have it to myself!
Mrs. Combs: Sugar Buzz in Cary, NC, NEVER disappoints. Their, Lemon Bar, is a delightful delicacy to be tried! There is a delicate crunch as you sink your teeth into the powdered sugar topped bar, just before your tongue captures its lemony sweetness.The, Coffee Cake, is a palatable treat! It is a soft, sweet, crunchy treat. I enjoy it without coffee, but I can imagine that coffee would take it to another level. ☺️The, Strawberry-Strawberry Cupcake, enveloped a pleasant surprise of strawberry jam or compote. It was so good! The customer service invites me to fill the largest box of goodies I can carry out of the door every time I visit the area. I love Sugar Buzz!
Alison Jamie Garscadden: Absolutely delicious! Staff was very nice and explained what was in each of the items I was looking at. Definitely coming back for more!
Patricia Dos Santos _ Staff - CarpenterES: I ordered my son's birthday cake here. I was very descriptive and showed pictures of the baseball themed diamond cake we wanted. When I arrived on Saturday, it was NOTHING like the pictures I sent them. It was such a disappointment. There were no details on the cake, it was a plain white cake with some green piping to make grass. I had asked for logos of baseball teams on the cake and there was just nothing. For $80 it was a complete rip off! I could've gotten a nicer cake at Publix with more detail for half the price. Won’t ever buy from this bakery again!!
Sarah True: I love this bakery! The staff work very hard to fulfill all requests. Everything I've ordered has been perfect and delicious. In a world of hoping a bakery has gluten free options that go beyond Chocolate Torte this place delivers! I have even begun using this bakery to fill orders for when I need a sweet treat to take to business meetings. Do yourself a favor and stop by for some flavor!
Jane: they’re always very friendly when I go. I have a sweet tooth and celiac. gluten free bakeries are few and far between. the other day I bought a chocolate chip cookie and some coffee cake, and they were both absolutely delicious. much better consistency than the gluten free baked goods im used to. The first time I ever went, I got some chocolate cake. it was incredibly moist. I’m waiting for the day that I go in and they have some again
V. Lori Fuller: Love this bakery! Their GF baked goods are stellar. I’m a frequent customer and have enjoyed each and every one of the yummy items I bought here.
Teresa Foster: Very disappointedCupcakes were obviously old. They were dried out. Sure not worth $5 each.
Victoria Martinez: My wife ordered a cake from here a month ago for my birthday on the 10th for this month. When we cut into the cake it was a unpleasant bite. We ordered a red velvet cake ( my favorite) and the bite itself was awful... you could taste the excess amount of flour in the cake, the cake had a grittiness to it which made it even more off-putting and the cream cheese icing was almost sour. I understand that red velvet is basically a chocolate cake, but the inside didn't even look like that bright red of a red velvet. The inside of this cake looked so dry and didn't even resemble a red velvet cake, this was a real disappointment because this bakery had great reviews but the cake was a major let down... especially since it's something I've been looking forward to for months and the cost itself was just a waste of money and a real big let down.
Robert Eyerly: Love this local bakery! At this point I’m a regular customer for their gluten free goodies. The chocolate chip cookies are the best, and gluten free but doesn’t taste like it. The eclair is really good too. So is the carrot cake, and the brownies. Just get one of everything!
Madison Lunger: Amazing bakery! The lady who worked the counter was patient and polite with us since it was our first time in there. We tried the brownie, a oatmeal cranberry cookie and the white chocolate raspberry bar. Everything was so good- cant wait to visit again :)
Kristen Butler: Delicious! A gluten free friend found it and was thrilled with the amount of selection she had! They were about to close (in an hour or so, we’re not monsters!) but still had a very good selection and were very sweet.
Nikita Kolb: Edit** They said it was a display one only and they sold it to my husband by mistake they are in the process of refunding us and we appreciate their apologies****Husband picked up valentine's box and the eclairs were full of mold. I have reccomend this place and I am so disappointed we will be returning it tomorrow attached are the photos. The mini cupcakes were also off. I left a message because they are already closed but please if you got the same do not eat it before cutting it open. They are closed mondays but we left a message and hopefully will hear back.
pennylouwho100: Husband bought me a birthday/ Valentine cake yesterday. Omg, best cake ever. Dense like pound cake, moist like regular cake and the buttercream was so thick, it taste Amazing!! Sorry, I didn't take a pic before it was cut.
Caitlin Williams: I love that the bakery has Gluten-free options, and that their options are more than just cupcakes. Each time I have been there they have had a wide variety of gluten-free goodies, such as scones, bars, apple almond cake, cheesecake, eclairs, lemon bars, pound cake and even hot pockets. The owner is really sweet as are the other workers.
Karen Moore: Delicious as always!
Harmony Life: The best gluten-free birthday cake. Mine was lemon and raspberry. Delicious
Maxwell Embury: The best baked goods in Cary you have to try this place. The lemon square was delicious. The coconut cluster tastes amazing. The brownies are to die for. The raspberry white chocolate bar was decadent. The chocolate mousse pie was out of this world. Sadly couldn't take any pictures due to lack of self control.

6. Custom Confections, LLC - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 78 reviews

1187 W Chatham St, Cary, NC 27513

Address Website
Custom Confections, LLC: what do users think?
Dustin “CrapbagMcgee” Martin: Best cheesecake around. Worth every penny.
Dave C: Our first time there to try the cheesecake. The one person there was less than enthusiastic, with no customer service skills. Asked for recommendations, and he said the plain was most popular and noted the top shelf was also popular. We got the peanut butter cup, and it was just so so. IF we return, it would be to try the plain, but I doubt we'll return.
Rachael Healy: Good cheesecakes. Great variety. Friendly staff! Definitely worth it to pick up your own cheesecake instead of using the delivery services. My family and I purchased a few flavors to try: almond joy, death by chocolate, pb cup, white chocolate raspberry, and tiramisu along with a lemon bar and PB bar. My favorite was the almond joy. This is the second time I’ve had the death by chocolate and both times the flourless torte part of it tastes like PB and it’s probably because it’s next to the PB cup in the showcase. I do wish the crusts weren’t as crumbly on them, they often fell apart not making it on the fork with the rest of the cheesecake. Definitely a great spot to get some cheesecake!
Christian Bunce: I love this place and the service was amazing, Lucas was a great help and very friendly. I loved the cheesecakes and cannolis were amazing too. Will be revisiting!!!!!
Sarah Jandora: Ordered a half triple chocolate and half triple treat cheesecake for a birthday and it was entirely too good! The triple treat was absolute perfection and the chocolate lovers also raved about their side. Customer service was extremely friendly and helpful. We will definitely be back.
Knox Hutchinson: Lucas Rivas Flores is the best employee I have ever seen. I love him. The cheesecake was good too.
Liz Moore: This place is a gorgeous slice of cheesecake heaven in Cary! Rylan is lovely as well. Thank you for the yummies!! ❤️
Vogue Elder: I was visiting from out of town, and always try to check out local fare. I’m glad I tried this place out. They had a nice amount of options by the slice, especially considering that I went a few minutes before closing. I ended up getting slices of the caramel macchiato and the death by chocolate cheesecakes. They were both rich and delicious. The caramel was good, but I didn’t get a lot of coffee flavor. The chocolate was really rich, and it took 3 days to eat the whole slice, but I’m not complaining. It was definitely good. I recommend this place, and will stop by again if I’m in the area.
Feyzan C: Best cheesecakes i have had in a long time
dolar khachariya: I ordered 2 slices of cakes from this place through doordash today and after waiting for 2 hours I have only received plain ice.
Steve Doherty: REALLY good bakery. Hidden gem!
D Mac: Cheesecakes are to die for
Darlene Tian: The Black and White Cheesecake is heavenly. Thank you for making our 70th Birthday special with this dessert.
Marcia White: Can't wait to get back to Cary to get more of this cheesecake. I had the carmel mocchiato it was so creamy and delicious. It will be hard to pick a different flavor. But the white chocolate raspberry might be calling my name.
Carah Stoudemire: Everything that I have tried from here is amazing, and their prices are as well! I would definitely recommend this place if you are looking for cheesecake or dessert in general!
Alex Granados: I love their cheesecakes. Homemade taste.Love it
John & Natasha Ford: Absolutely amazing! We love getting our dessert here!
Brandie M. Taylor: Delicious cheesecake flavors and awesome customer service 😋
Ray Bowles: I like it on the special occasions when there is cannoli.
Edith Tudo Sierra: The best cheesecake.
Lana Lynch: I've probably tried every single flavor of cheesecake from here over the last few years and they have all been super delish! Can't say enough good things about the product and the staff! Cary is lucky to have you! :)

7. Smallcakes - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 166 reviews

1132 Parkside Main St, Cary, NC 27519

Address Website WhatsApp

8. La Farm Bakery - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 493 reviews

220 W Chatham St, Cary, NC 27511

Address Website WhatsApp

9. Cinnaholic - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 194 reviews

1209 Parkside Main St, Cary, NC 27519

Address Website WhatsApp

10. Great Harvest Bread Co - Cary - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 227 reviews

1240 NW Maynard Rd, Cary, NC 27513

Address Website WhatsApp

11. Annelore's German Bakery - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 436 reviews

308 W Chatham St, Cary, NC 27511

Address Website WhatsApp

12. La Michoacana Bakery - Cary

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 172 reviews

114 SW Maynard Rd, Cary, NC 27511

Address WhatsApp

13. Insomnia Cookies - Raleigh

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 910 reviews

2302 Hillsborough St, Raleigh, NC 27607

Address Website WhatsApp

add a comment of Cookie shop Cary

Comment sent successfully! We will review it in the next few hours.